An independent AI advisor for decisions that are expensive and hard to reverse

Handed an AI decision with a date on it, or running a company on an AI product you can't check yourself? I'm an independent AI advisor: I give you a technical judgement on the whole system, people included, with no vendor to recommend and no build work to sell you afterwards.

Dr Colin Kelly

PhD in NLP (Cambridge)

Former Head of Applied AI Research

Fully independent. No vendor affiliation, no implementation upsell

What an independent AI advisor does

You know how you get a survey before you buy a house? An independent AI advisor does that for an AI decision. I look at the model, the data, the engineering and the people who'll run it and use it, and I check the claims made for each. Then I tell you what's real, what it will cost to keep working, and what has to change before you commit.

The report leaves you with four options, much as a survey does: go ahead, change the plan, set conditions, or stop. What it doesn't do is turn into a quote for the repairs, because I don't do the repairs. That one rule is what makes the advice independent, and it's the reason you can put the findings in front of a board or an investment committee without anyone asking what I stood to gain.

For leaders who own an AI decision and have to take it to a non-technical board, that judgement comes as advisory. For founders with an AI product, it comes as an architect review or a fractional AI CTO role. For investors and acquirers, it comes as AI due diligence.

Why independence matters

Plenty of people can tell you about AI. Far fewer can tell you about it without a product, a partnership or a follow-on project shaping the answer. Independence here is structural, and it comes down to four commitments.

No build work on anything I assess

If I've assessed a company for you, I don't take build or remediation work from it afterwards. The findings can't become a pitch for my own next engagement.

No vendor affiliation

I'm not a partner, reseller or referrer for any AI vendor, platform or model provider. When I compare options, nobody is paying me for the answer.

The person you brief does the work

I read the code, run the interviews and write the report myself. There is no junior team behind the senior face on the first call.

Paid by you, and only you

The fee comes from the person making the decision, so the advice answers to that decision and nothing else. I'll tell you quickly if it's not a fit.

Who hires an independent AI advisor

Leaders handed an AI decision

A board, a chair or a reorg has given you an AI decision with a date on it, and you're not a technologist. You need a read you can defend in the room, on the technology and on the people who'll have to make it work, from someone with no stake in the outcome.

Founders with an AI product and a small team

The build sits with a few engineers or a contractor, and an investor, a buyer or an enterprise customer is about to test it. You need someone who can read the system, tell you what will hold, and help the team decide what to build next.

Executives choosing a vendor or platform

Supplier demos are convincing. You want someone who has built these systems to tell you what will hold up in production and what the switching costs look like.

Investors and acquirers

Pricing a deal where the AI is a large part of the value. You need to know whether the AI is worth the price, and whether the advantage will last, before the money moves.

What I do, and what I don't

For leaders who own an AI decision and have to carry it to a board, AI leadership advisory covers what's worth doing, in what order, and what it will cost. If your team has built an AI tool, an independent AI architect review is a second pair of eyes on it, before more people rely on it. For founders without a senior technical lead, I can step in as a fractional CTO. The companies I do that for are never ones I've assessed for an investor.

For investors and acquirers, AI due diligence is a separate service: a two-week technical assessment, with a written report that gives a severity rating on each finding. It also runs sell-side, for founders who want the AI verified before a buyer's diligence starts.

What I don't do is build. I'll design, assess and advise on an AI system, and I'll help you choose who builds it, but I don't build the thing I've just surveyed.

Who you're dealing with

Independence only counts if the judgement behind it is sound. I've built AI systems and led the teams that build them, which is how I know which claims to test first and where production systems break.

  • PhD in Natural Language Processing, University of Cambridge, and a BA in Mathematics and Computer Science from Oxford
  • Over fifteen years building and assessing AI systems, across IBM, PA Consulting and two VC-backed AI scale-ups
  • Former Head of Applied AI Research, leading the team delivering production AI capabilities
  • Identified over €50m in AI value at IBM across telecoms, financial services and automotive
  • Twenty months as fractional CTO taking an AI product from concept to public beta
  • AI strategy for the communications division of a major global philanthropic foundation
More about Dr Colin Kelly

Frequently Asked Questions

How does an independent AI advisor differ from a large consultancy?

An independent AI advisor has no implementation practice and no partner programme, while a large firm usually has one or both, so its advice sits next to something it would like to sell you. Agathon takes no build work on anything it assesses, and the person you brief is also the person who reads the code, runs the interviews and writes the report.

Does an independent AI advisor recommend specific AI vendors or tools?

As an independent AI advisor, Agathon tells you which AI vendors or tools fit your situation, what each one will cost you over time and where it breaks. I don't take referral fees or partner commissions, so the answer doesn't change depending on who you pick.

Does Agathon build what it recommends?

Agathon does not sell implementation or remediation on anything it assesses. Where I act as an independent AI architect or fractional CTO, it's for a company I haven't assessed on someone else's behalf. You can be the buyer's surveyor or the architect on a house, and I don't do both on the same one.

What does an independent AI advisory engagement look like?

An engagement with Agathon as your independent AI advisor starts with a conversation about the decision you're making and what would change it. Advisory for leaders is an ongoing relationship, scaled up during hiring or major technical decisions and down in between. For a founder with an AI product, it can start with an architect review of what's been built, or a fractional CTO role, typically one to three days a week. AI due diligence, a separate service for investors and acquirers, runs as a two-week assessment with a written report and a live debrief, priced from $15,000.

Does Agathon work under NDA as an independent AI advisor?

Agathon works under NDA on every independent AI advisory engagement. All engagements are fully confidential.

Does independent AI advice include an investment recommendation?

Agathon's independent AI advice does not include an investment recommendation, because that decision depends on factors beyond the technology. The advice gives a technical verdict on each claim, its severity, and what each finding means for the decision in front of you. For a founder or operator, the decision itself stays with you and your board.

Weighing up a large firm against an independent? Read Big 4 consultant vs independent AI advisor.

Tell me about the decision

A short conversation about what you're deciding and what would change it. I'll tell you quickly if it's not a fit.

The Agathon Briefing
A regular note with two or three thoughts on seeing the whole AI system clearly, people included, from someone who assesses those systems for a living. Written by hand, read in five minutes.
No more than one briefing a month